Reviews: Tilloo Cay

These are observations from the boating community. Waterway Guide information is verified regularly and all efforts will be made to validate any new updates submitted here. Thank you for taking the time to share comments about your experience.

Waterway Guide reserves the option of editing reviews and comments for grammar, clarity and the removal of defamatory or potentially slanderous language. When appropriate, reviews are forwarded to businesses for response prior to being made public. We will make every effort to be objective and impartial when posting reviews, but do not publicize details of disputes between parties.

Thanks for your valuable feedback!
Holding:
4.67
Good, Grass, Sand
Wind Protection:
4.00
Open and exposed to south and southwest
Current Flow:
4.00
Wake Protection:
3.33
Open and exposed to south and southwest
Scenic Beauty:
4.33
Ease of Shopping:
1.00
Shore Access:
1.00
Pet Friendly:
1.00
Cell Service:
2.00

  • Review for Tilloo Cay

    Reviewed by: TarA Glowczewskie on Feb 17, 2025
    Vessel Type: Sail
    LOA: 44'
    Draft: 4.5'

    Overall Rating:
    4
    Holding:
    5
    Wind Protection:
    5
    Current Flow:
    5
    Wake Protection:
    3
    Scenic Beauty:
    5
    Shore Access:
    1

    Great protection from north and east winds.
    Good fishing for small snapper, grunts,and "flats"fish.
    The water is 6 or 7 Feet at low tide almost to the shore but not suitable for anchoring if you want to avoid fouling your chain!
    We picked up an old tree limb and a shopping cart on the same drop while trying to tuck in 400 feet from shore.
    Try anchoring out 800 or 900 feet from shore in 10 feet or more for a cleaner bottom…. Or have your flippers and mask ready just in case

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer


  • Review for Tilloo Cay

    Reviewed by: Jason Spitz on Apr 13, 2024
    Vessel Type: Sail
    LOA: 40'
    Draft: 4.0'

    Overall Rating:
    4
    Holding:
    4
    Wind Protection:
    4
    Current Flow:
    4
    Wake Protection:
    2
    Scenic Beauty:
    4
    Ease of Shopping:
    1
    Shore Access:
    1
    Pet Friendly:
    1
    Cell Service:
    2

    This is a nice spot for N to SE winds. You can tuck in pretty far or stay out a bit. Plenty of room for quite a few boats. Expect some residual wakes from those transiting north/south to Tahiti beach area. This is a calmer place to be than Tahiti and you can easily dinghy up. We searched the anchorage for possible snorkeling. There are rocks in the anchorage close to the homes with their own docks and sea walls. No coral growth but lots of reef fish in the area. Bottom in the anchorage is generally sand and sea grass. Lots of turtles. Look for sandy spots. Beware of sunken debris including at least two long dock pilings, a cement mooring, and other tree limbs and rocks. Don't miss the old Far Side Castle Turret while you're anchored here. Cell service TMobile was 1 bar.

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer


  • Review for Tilloo Cay

    Reviewed by: Jennifer Nicolai, Friend Ship, on Nov 3, 2017
    Vessel Type: Sail
    LOA: 40'
    Draft: 5.0'

    Overall Rating:
    4
    Holding:
    5
    Wind Protection:
    3
    Current Flow:
    3
    Wake Protection:
    5
    Scenic Beauty:
    4

    A lovely shelter in N through SE wind. Excellent holding, little traffic.

    View location on the Waterway Guide Explorer

View in Waterway Explorer